top of page

Judgement

Judgement is a fundamental aspect of life; arguably the most important aspect of life. Judgment acts as the foundation for decisions in every aspect of life—personal, professional, spiritual, and social.

 

The importance of not passing judgment on others and embracing unconditional love are foundational/universal principle in many philosophical, spiritual, and ethical traditions.

 

The effects of judgment extend far beyond individual outcomes and impact families, communities, the environment and more. Positive judgments can lead to harmony, peace, and prosperity, in individuals and in larger groups, while poor judgments can contribute to conflict and suffering, both inward and outward. 

 

In essence, judgment is not just a personal capacity but a pivotal axis around which societies balance ethical norms, legal systems, and cultural values. Improving our judgment and encouraging others to develop theirs can contribute significantly to personal growth and collective well-being.

THE IMPORTANCE OF NOT PASSING JUDGEMENT

1. Human Fallibility: Limited Understanding: Humans often lack all the information about others' circumstances, backgrounds, and the reasons behind their actions. Judgments made without full understanding can be flawed and unjust. Recognizing our limitations in discerning the full truth encourages humility and patience in forming opinions about others.

2. Compassion and Empathy: Relating to Others' Experiences: Not passing judgment fosters compassion and empathy, allowing us to connect with others in a more meaningful and supportive way. Understanding that everyone faces struggles and challenges helps in extending kindness rather than criticism.

3. Spiritual and Moral Values: Following Spiritual Teachings: Many spiritual traditions, including Christianity, Buddhism, Hinduism, and Islam, teach the importance of non-judgment and love. For instance, Jesus' teaching, "Judge not, that you be not judged," underscores this principle in Christianity. Similarly, Buddhist practices encourage seeing the innate goodness in all beings, which aligns with showing unconditional love.

4. Psychological Well-being: Avoiding Negativity: Passing judgment often involves negative emotions, such as anger, resentment, or superiority. These emotions can be harmful to one's mental health. Practicing unconditional love, on the other hand, is associated with positive emotions and mental states, such as joy, peace, and contentment.

5. Social Harmony: Promoting Peace and Understanding: By withholding judgment and practicing unconditional love, societies can promote more peaceful and cooperative interactions. This approach reduces conflicts, misunderstandings, and promotes inclusiveness and tolerance.

6. Personal Growth: Developing Virtues: Practicing non-judgment and unconditional love challenges individuals to grow in virtues such as patience, kindness, and generosity. These virtues not only improve personal character but also impact others positively.

7. Karmic and Cosmic Principles: Influencing One’s Karma: In traditions that believe in karma, every action, including mental actions like judgment, impacts one's karmic balance. By choosing non-judgment and love, one is aligning with positive karmic influences.

8. Universal Connection: Recognizing Interconnectedness: Philosophical and spiritual doctrines often emphasize the interconnected nature of all life. By understanding our deep connections to others, the logic of unconditional love becomes clear—what benefits one can benefit all, and harm done to one can harm all.

The practice of non-judgment and unconditional love is not about ignoring wrongdoing or foregoing discernment but is about approaching life with a mindset that seeks to understand, support, and uplift rather than condemn. This approach can transform personal interactions and lead to a more compassionate and inclusive humanity.

JUDGEMENT IN RELIGIOUS TEXT

The Bible addresses the concept of judgment extensively, discussing it from various angles including divine judgment by God, personal judgment regarding moral decisions, and the judgment of others. Here are some key themes and scriptures related to judgment in the Bible:

1. Divine Judgment:

  • Final Judgment: Scriptures such as Matthew 25:31-46 describe the final judgment where individuals are judged by God based on their actions and the nature of their faith.

  • Judgment of Nations: Books like Daniel and Revelation describe scenarios where nations are judged based on their treatment of others and their adherence to God's commands.

2. Judgment Among People:

  • Admonition Against Judging Others: Matthew 7:1-2 warns against judging others harshly or hypocritically. "Do not judge, or you too will be judged. For in the same way you judge others, you will be judged, and with the measure you use, it will be measured to you."

  • Righteous Judgment: John 7:24 advises, "Do not judge by appearances, but judge with right judgment." This suggests using wise discernment, based on truth and not on superficial factors.

3. Moral and Ethical Judgment:

  • Wisdom in Judgment: Proverbs is a book filled with advice on how to exercise sound judgment and wisdom in various aspects of life.

  • Discerning Good from Evil: Hebrews 5:14 emphasizes the maturity of those who through practice have powers of discernment trained to distinguish good from evil.

4. Accountability and Self-Judgment:

  • Examining Oneself: 1 Corinthians 11:31-32 discusses the importance of judging oneself rightly to avoid being judged along with the world. "But if we judged ourselves truly, we would not be judged."

5. Mercy Over Judgment:

  • Mercy Triumphs Over Judgment: James 2:13 states that mercy triumphs over judgment, highlighting the virtue of mercy in the context of interpersonal judgments.

The Bible promotes a view of judgment that is balanced between divine principles and the complex realities of human morality and social interaction. The overarching message is one of using judgment wisely, exercising mercy, and leaving the ultimate judgment to God.

The Quran, like the Bible, addresses the concept of judgment extensively, covering aspects of divine judgment, the day of judgment, and guidelines for personal conduct to ensure fairness and justice. Here are some key themes related to judgment in the Quran:

1.The Day of Judgment (Yawm al-Qiyamah):

  • The Quran frequently refers to the Day of Judgment, where all individuals will be resurrected for God's final assessment of their deeds. This day is described in detail across various surahs (chapters), emphasizing its inevitability and the comprehensive evaluation of everyone's actions.

2. Divine Judgment:

  • Allah (God) as the Ultimate Judge: Numerous verses describe Allah as the ultimate and most just judge, who alone has the authority to judge mankind. For example, Surah Al-An'am (6:57) states, "The command rests with none but Allah: He declares the truth, and He is the best of judges."

  • Accountability: Every person is accountable to Allah for their deeds, good or bad, and each will be compensated justly on the Day of Judgment (Surah Al-Zalzalah 99:7-8).

3. Moral and Social Judgment:

  • Justice and Fairness: The Quran commands believers to uphold justice strictly, even if it concerns themselves or close relatives. Surah An-Nisa (4:135) advises, "O ye who believe! Stand out firmly for justice, as witnesses to Allah, even as against yourselves, or your parents, or your kin, and whether it be (against) rich or poor..."

  • Avoiding Hypocrisy and Misjudgment: There are warnings against hypocrisy and making judgments based on ignorance. Believers are advised to verify information and avoid assumptions (Surah Al-Hujurat 49:6).

4. Guidance for Rulers and Judges:

  • Impartiality in Judgment: Instructions are given for those in positions of authority to judge with righteousness and not to let hatred of others lead them away from justice (Surah Al-Maidah 5:8).

  • Consultation and Decision Making: The Quran also emphasizes consultation and collective decision-making in governance, which reflects a balanced approach to judgment in leadership roles.

5. Mercy in Judgment:

  • Emphasis on Forgiveness: While strict justice is upheld, the Quran also strongly emphasizes mercy and forgiveness. Believers are encouraged to forgive others, as Allah is merciful and forgiving (Surah Al-A'raf 7:199).

These teachings highlight a dual focus on both divine cosmic judgment and practical guidance for everyday ethical and judicial decisions. The ultimate goal is to foster a society where justice prevails, and individuals are conscious of their final accountability before Allah.

The Bhagavad Gita, a seminal text in Hindu philosophy, offers profound insights on the concept of judgment, particularly focusing on moral discernment, righteous action, and the importance of intentionality in decision-making. Below are some of the key teachings from the Gita that relate to judgment:

1. Dharma (Righteous Duty):

  • Adherence to One's Duty: The Gita emphasizes the importance of adhering to one's 'dharma' (duty) based on one's role and status in society. Lord Krishna advises Arjuna to perform his duty as a warrior, even when faced with moral dilemmas such as fighting against relatives. This duty should be performed without attachment to outcomes, which implies a form of judgment that is pure and not influenced by personal gain or loss.

2. Karma (Action):

  • Action without Attachment: Krishna counsels Arjuna on the concept of 'karma yoga', which is the yoga of selfless action performed for the divine without attachment to results. This teaches a form of judgment that is detached and objective, focusing on right action rather than personal benefit.

3. Jnana (Knowledge):

  •   Wisdom in Judgment: The Gita discusses 'jnana yoga', the path of knowledge, which highlights the importance of wisdom and understanding in making judgments. True knowledge leads to enlightenment, which is the realization of the self's immortality and the impermanence of the material world.

4. Bhakti (Devotion):

  • Divine Guidance in Decision-Making: In the path of 'bhakti yoga', devotion to God is highlighted. Surrender to the divine will is seen as a supreme form of judgment, where personal ego and preferences are set aside in favor of divine guidance and will.

5. Detachment and Equanimity:

  • Balanced Judgment: Krishna teaches that one should maintain equanimity in success and failure, pleasure and pain. This balanced state of mind aids in sound judgment, allowing one to make decisions that are not clouded by emotional biases.

6. Ethics and Morality:

  • Moral Judgment: The Gita makes it clear that ethical considerations and moral values should guide one's decisions. Actions should contribute to the welfare of society and be in harmony with universal ethics.

7. Discernment between the Real and the Unreal:

  •  Viveka (Discernment): A crucial aspect of judgment in the Gita is the ability to discern the real from the unreal, meaning recognizing the eternal spirit beyond the temporary material manifestations.

Through these teachings, the Bhagavad Gita provides a comprehensive framework for judgment that incorporates ethical integrity, selfless action, spiritual knowledge, and devotion. It urges individuals to make decisions that are aligned with divine will and the greater good, rather than personal desires.

The I Ching or "Book of Changes" offers nuanced perspectives on judgment, primarily in the context of decision-making and understanding the consequences of actions within the cosmic and moral order it outlines. Here are some key principles from the I Ching related to judgment:

1. Harmony with the Tao:

  • Aligning Decisions with Cosmic Order: The I Ching emphasizes making decisions that harmonize with the Tao, the underlying principle that governs all changes in the universe. Judgment, in this context, involves discerning the appropriate time and manner to act in accordance with the natural flow of events.

2. Understanding Change:

  • Reading Signs and Patterns: The I Ching is a tool used to interpret the patterns of the yin (passive, receptive, dark) and yang (active, creative, bright) forces in life. Effective judgment, according to the I Ching, requires understanding how these dynamic forces interact and influence current and future circumstances. This is crucial for deciding when to act or refrain from action.

3. Wisdom and Moral Integrity:

  • Consulting the Oracle Wisely: Users of the I Ching ask questions and then cast yarrow sticks or coins to generate a hexagram, which interprets the situation at hand. The quality of one's judgment when using the I Ching also depends on the sincerity and clarity of the question posed. This process encourages introspection and ethical consideration.

4. Adaptability:

  • Flexibility in Response: The I Ching teaches that good judgment involves adaptability and the ability to change one's course of action based on new information and changing situations. This is metaphorically represented through the transformation of hexagrams, where lines change from yin to yang and vice versa.

5. Prudence and Caution:

  • Avoiding Rash Decisions: Several hexagrams directly counsel caution and deliberation. For example, Hexagram 4 (Meng, Youthful Folly) warns about the dangers of foolishness in inexperienced judgments, advocating for learning and seeking knowledge before making decisions.

6. Balance and Fairness:

  • Equitable Consideration: The I Ching often highlights the need for balance between different elements and perspectives, reflecting the belief that fair judgment accounts for all sides and avoids extremities.

The I Ching does not provide direct moral commandments or laws as found in some religious texts, but rather it offers a framework for thinking through decisions and their implications in a deeply interconnected universe. Judgment, in the I Ching, is about understanding cycles, recognizing the timing of actions, and aligning oneself with the greater harmonies and rhythms of life.

Learn New and Useful Things About Life Weekly! CLICK HERE! to Become a Member (13).png
bottom of page